Best of the Best Best Bartender winner Chris Cap reflects on decades behind the bar, classic cocktails, and creating happiness.
best of the best · best bartender
Chris Cap can make a great Old Fashioned almost anywhere. His recipe for a truly bad decision is another story.
Chris Cap can make a great Old Fashioned in a properly stocked bar. He can also make one in a coffee cup—or, he jokes, even a shoe if the situation demands it. The tools are useful, but they are not what makes someone a bartender. After decades in hospitality, Cap knows the real craft has much more to do with people than it does with shakers, strainers or carefully placed garnishes.
“Forget about learning drinks,” he says. “Learn how to talk to people, engage them, be attentive and be able to do a million things at once.”
That philosophy has been shaped by a career that began when Cap was about 14 years old, washing dishes at La Gondola. He went on to work as a host, server, bartender and manager at The Alchemist and Barrister, followed by nearly 19 years as a bartender, bar manager and clubhouse manager at Trenton Country Club. Today, he is behind the bar at Al’s Airport Inn, doing what he describes simply as “creating happiness.”
It is a phrase that has stayed with him for years. While introducing himself to the staff at Trenton Country Club, Cap announced, “I’m Chris Cap, and I make drinks.” The dining manager immediately corrected him: “No, dude. You create happiness.”
Another lesson came from a sign displayed by a former manager: “The restaurant is the train, and the bartender is the engineer.” Together, those two ideas became the foundation of Cap’s approach to hospitality.
“We create happiness while keeping the party going—and, of course, under control,” he says.
Cap was born in Chambersburg and grew up along the Hamilton–Trenton border, an area he affectionately calls “Tramilton.” As a teenage dishwasher at La Gondola, he found himself fascinated by bartenders Bob and Jerome. He watched the ease of their movements and the way they talked with customers. Their confidence and gift of gab made the job look like something more than preparing drinks; they were setting the tone for the entire room.
Before he ever worked behind a bar, Cap began collecting cocktail recipes from magazine advertisements and making drinks for friends. The first was a Lynchburg Lemonade, served in high school graduation mugs at a vacation house in Wildwood. A few years later, his brother Dave and best friend Ken were working at The Alchemist and Barrister when manager Jimmy hired Cap as a host. From there, he moved up to waiter and eventually bartender.
What has kept him in the profession is the unpredictability—and the opportunity to change the direction of someone’s day.
“It’s a party every night,” he says. “I really enjoy putting smiles on people’s faces and providing an escape from everyday life. Every shift is different, so it never gets stale.”
He cannot choose one customer encounter as the most memorable. For him, the lasting impression comes from a transformation he has witnessed countless times: someone arrives in a bad mood, begins to relax and ultimately leaves saying they had a blast.
“When someone’s mood goes from bad to good with the experience I provide, that makes my night.”
Cap is a purist when it comes to technique. He respects the classics and believes their tried-and-true methods provide everything a bartender needs. His favorite drinks to make are the Old Fashioned and the Cosmopolitan, both of which have classic foundations that can be adjusted to suit the person ordering.
Flavor comes before spectacle. Cap builds a cocktail by considering the balance among sweet, sour, savory and bitter elements. Presentation has its place, but it should never compensate for what is in the glass.
That does not mean he cannot appreciate some showmanship. He admires the Basque tradition of pouring wine from high above the glass—a dramatic technique that also aerates the wine. Still, when asked which tools he could not live without, his list is tellingly practical: an apron, a notebook, a waiter’s-friend wine opener and “a thousand pens.”
Cap hopes the industry’s next major trend is a return to basics. Technology may produce faster pours and novel experiences, but he does not believe drink-making machines or self-pour beer stations can replace a bartender.
“They are fun for, like, a minute,” he says, “but you can’t get a joke out of one to save your life.”
For Cap, that human interaction is the point. Craft cocktails may have elevated the public perception of bartending, but precise recipes and elaborate garnishes are only part of the work. A bartender has to read the room, remember details, manage competing demands, start conversations and make people feel welcome—all while maintaining responsibility for everyone’s safety.
The most challenging skill he has learned is recognizing when it is time to stop serving someone.
“You have to realize the responsibility you have to ensure safety while providing a good time,” he says.
Recently, a customer insulted Cap after he refused to serve him a double. Cap did not reconsider. He declined to serve the man and asked him to leave. Hospitality may be about creating happiness, but it also requires boundaries.
Cap believes bartenders can have a meaningful effect on their communities, particularly when they work for socially minded establishments that welcome everyone. He often introduces guests seated beside each other, breaking the ice and encouraging them to look up from their screens.
“It helps open minds and create camaraderie,” he says.
Charity has also been part of his career. Early on, The Alchemist and Barrister held a “Longbeard” contest for a local charity, and one year Cap tied for the win. His name remains on a plaque there. The restaurant also held guest-bartender events in which portions of the tips were donated.
More recently, Al’s Airport Inn hosted a cocktail contest with proceeds from each drink benefiting the bartender’s chosen charity. Cap selected an organization serving homeless veterans, a cause made personal by the ongoing experience of a close friend. His cocktail did not win—the honor went to Carissa’s extremely popular “Rubber Ducky You’re the One”—but the event reflected the kind of establishment and community connection he values.
Carissa also helps keep him current on sweeter, garnish-driven cocktails. Cap jokes that she keeps him in touch with his “sweet side.” His own tastes remain grounded in the classics—very far from a concoction he imagines for a truly bad decision: Chicago’s famously bitter Malört dropped into a Red Bull. His description is less than restrained, and his predicted outcome is “getting ready to break out in handcuffs.”
Away from work, Cap is married and has a 24-year-old son, David, who lives in Philadelphia. At home, he and his family share their lives with Billy, a rescued shepherd–husky mix, and Simba, a very vocal orange tabby. Over the years, the household has included several more cats and a couple of dogs.
He enjoys live music and casually plays bass, drums, guitar and keyboards. He also collects vintage G.I. Joe, He-Man and Star Wars action figures. “I’m a nerd at heart,” he says.
He casually follows football and hockey, but live hockey at any level is the real draw—a connection to the many hours of street hockey he played as a child. His own school football career was less distinguished. He says his primary position was “left bench.” That quick self-deprecating humor was encouraged by two favorite high school teachers, Mr. Policare and Italian teacher Mr. Schirber, both of whom shared a sharp wit and, as Cap puts it, liked to break his stones.
After so many years in hospitality, his definition of success has changed. During his country-club career, success meant climbing toward the highest level of management, sometimes at the expense of his personal and family life. Today, his priorities are different.
“Now it’s all about life-to-work balance,” he says, “with life coming first.”
If he could bartend anywhere, he would follow that balance—and the seasons: a ski-resort bar in winter and a beach bar in summer. Wherever the bar happens to be, the essentials would remain the same. The classics would be made properly. The room would be kept under control. Strangers would be introduced. Jokes would be told. And Chris Cap would continue doing much more than making drinks.
He would be creating happiness.